Update January 12, 2022: After this article was published, Northeastern University revised the information it provided regarding its merit aid distribution. The university says 59% of 2021-22 first-year enrollees who fail to demonstrate any financial need still receive the aid they deserve. Northeastern also removes from part of its website any reference to a number that could help students determine their likelihood of receiving the support they deserve. As of January 11, the website only states that Northeastern has awarded deserving scholarships to “selected students”. According to the university, “the attempt to forecast meritorious aid awards on our website is unnecessarily misleading.”
When you agree to purchase an on-demand product or service if it’s available, you’ll know what the pre-commitment price will be.
But in the world of college admissions and early decision, where you commit to attending if one school offers you one, you don’t always know ahead of time the different – if any – discounts that many schools offer. provided for each student.
This is a big deal if you’re not sure you can afford the school. If you can’t get a quote and you don’t want to make an early decision, you won’t take advantage of the better admission rates that often exist when you apply that way.
Entering Northeastern University in Boston, a prime example of high school that doesn’t always predict how much aid many applicants will receive — an amount that can lead to a final price increase of $100,000 or more during college years. While checking out their website in recent weeks, I also noticed that a key statistic college shoppers need when assessing their help rate seems to have dropped by at least 20 percentage points .
Northeast, yes self transform From a working school to a highly aesthetic school in just a few decades, it’s not alone. The price prediction mechanism of the University of Connecticut and New York University has similar shortcomings. Last month, at my urgingNYU has taken down an admissions office blog post filled with inaccurate initial decision information.
All of this badass highlights a problem that persists at too many of the upper echelons of the higher education industry: When it comes time to make this huge, emotional purchase, it’s all too often. you do not know before you sign up and get what the actual price will be.
So what are we talking about when we talk about price discounts that come from “aid” and the predictability of college shoppers? Schools don’t always make it obvious.
First, there is support that schools have based on the financial need demonstrated by the student or family. In this category, families get a fair bit of help in determining what might happen to them. The federal government requires schools to provide something called net price calculatorand it predicts what kind of support the university can provide to those who cannot afford to pay the full price.
The other major type of aid that organizations provide is called deserving aid. It’s more murky.
Either way, a lot of wealthy families don’t qualify for need-based subsidies. Many of them believe that they cannot afford the retail price without some worthy support. Cry them a river, but if you make $300,000 a year and live in an expensive area, writing a $75,000 tuition receipt, after taxes, might not be easy. Schools know this, which is part of the reason why most of them offer merit aid.
Some colleges will predict what support you might be able to get – which they determine by finding out if they like your grades and test scores or other things about your application – before you sign an early decision agreement. Others, like Northeastern, won’t do that in their real price calculator.
Why not? A big reason, according to Sundar KumarasamyNortheastern vice president of admissions management, is that these calculators can feed test scores and scores through some sort of rubric or other way of identifying and predicting achievement support — but they have limitations. quality limitations.
“How will a student with an arts profile compete with someone who knows how math and science works and does well on tests?” Mr. Kumarasamy said.
This makes sense, but it’s also quite frustrating for families who just want to know – within six figures at least! – what they might have to pay within four or five years. Whitman College in Washington and University of Wooster in Ohio, it is indeed a virtue – and indeed a marketing strategy – to advise individual families who want to read up early on the kind of deserving support their application can receive.
It’s not a great look for Northeastern as it tells the world on its awards support page that “students who are in the 10-15% of our top applicant pool are considered for awards.” rewards support competitive success.” When I first read that number a few weeks ago, I could recognize the magnetic field data is published separately that the percentage of undergrads receiving deserving aid is higher than that might suggest.
I asked, just to be sure, and 36 percent of freshmen who have not demonstrated financial need still receive the aid they deserve. At my request, Northeastern website update to reflect these odds.
Northeastern’s use of the term “constraint” when making early decisions doesn’t make me entirely right either. Italicized on its websiteit instructs people: “Please note, Early Decision is binding – if you are admitted, you are committed to attending.”
But you do not. This is not a contract that schools attempt to enforce through some kind of legal mechanism, and each year, 2 to 3 percent of people who enter Northeastern through early decision decline the offer, mostly for financial reasons.
Early decisions are non-binding and Northeastern should say so on its website, using the same italics already there. (It’s really as simple as day into one of those actual initial decision agreements that schools eventually ask students, high school counselors, and parents to sign.)
And just to be clear, if you’re not getting the support you deserve that you feel you need to make the numbers work, some schools will let you skip the early admission decision.
“Any student who applies for, is admitted to the ED and finds the award of financial aid (need-based or merit-based aid, or a combination of the two) to be unreasonable has the right to withdraw his application. register at Conn and pursue higher education options elsewhere,” Andrew Strickler, dean of admissions and financial aid at Connecticut College, said by email. “I enthusiastically support the possibility of a student stopping to run for office at Conn under these circumstances.”
If you’re a student or parent struggling with college shopping, you should take that enthusiastic support as a kind of cue. You are not a beggar here; you are the consumer.
So how would Northeastern feel if you let go of the early acceptance decision if you weren’t getting any of the support you deserved – and so you felt that you couldn’t afford the school?
When I first asked this question to Mr. Kumarasamy, he thinks it’s a kind of game. I object to that, because many people don’t feel they can afford it $75,000 or so list price but can get it to work at $50,000 with that well-deserved aid discount. How does this play the system, I asked, when he didn’t inform them in advance if they could get that $25,000 discount?
Finally, he came around. “What is not good for students is not good for any of us,” he said. But he is also quick to point out the zero-sum nature of the original decision; if you bail when you’re accepted, you’ve taken the place of someone else – perhaps someone even more needy than you – who would love a shot at the beginning of your senior year and actually accept the offer of assistance. school financial aid.
“There is a difference between behavior that occurs in rare circumstances and behavior that we want to encourage,” Northeastern spokesman Michael Armini said by email.
I want to encourage that behavior a little more than Northeastern, and I expect college counselors in high schools to do the same.
It would be a lot easier without parsing any of this, but the decision will soon be up to us for a while as universities love it. When admissions administrators (as they often call themselves now) admit a large portion of a class at a time when students feel obligated to go if they are to participate, it allows schools to control control exactly what kind of students are in any given class – and how much revenue they’ll bring in.
So as long as we are stuck with a highly imperfect system, schools should show the percentage of students receiving the support they deserve in the early decision round, if they have one and also provide worthy support. All schools should also indicate the percentage of the entire class receiving deserving support and explain how they define the term.
They should say that early decisions are non-binding and that they should commit to not punishing prospective applicants from high schools where former applicants have neglected to accept early decisions. They should also clarify whether they have a problem with people who decline early decision offers because they are not getting the support they deserve.
Finally, if they don’t predict a worthy support in their net worth calculator, they should explain why and give people more information as to why some people receive the payout. support it and others do not.
I really don’t need to say all of this, or anything. I don’t need to revise their web pages in consecutive columns. And you don’t have to go into the process – and get out of it, in many cases – not knowing how the system actually works.
https://www.nytimes.com/2022/01/07/your-money/college-early-decision-northeastern-merit-aid.html Support for University Rewards (or lack of support) Make decisions as early as ever Murkier